John Chow dot Com Free WordPress Installation - Start Your Blog Today!
 

How To Handle Negative Comments In A Blog

written by John Chow on April 18, 2007

Make Money!

I’ve been noticing an increase in negative comments in the blog. The commentators aren’t happy with the level of advertising, number of ReviewMe reviews, promotion of AGLOCO, food posts, etc. They warn that the blog is not what it used to be, that I am on a slippery slope, and that my traffic will go down if I continue on this path. My reply to all this is, “Thanks for making my blog bigger.”

Negative Comments Are A Good Thing

I actually look forward to negative comments in my blog because it’s an indication of growth. This is a general rule to keep in mind: as your blog gets bigger, the number of negative comments increases. Therefore, don’t look at negative comments in a blog as a bad thing. It’s really a good thing – your blog is growing! Evil rule to remember: if you’re not pissing somebody off, you’re not doing it right.

This does not mean you should purposely try to piss readers off. That would be stupid. What is does mean is you cannot please everyone all the time and you shouldn’t even try. That goal is not possible no matter how much we wish for it. The blogsphere is too diverse a place for everyone to be happy with what you have to say or do.

Negative Comments Encourage Discussions

Let’s face it, a blog comment section would be pretty boring if everyone replied, “Great post! I completely agree with you.” Having a negative comment show up in a post encourages discussions among the readership. It’s the same as a flame war in a forum. While many people say flame wars are bad, most forum owners won’t stop it once it starts because it generates a lot of traffic and traffic equals money.

This is one reason why I allow negative comments on the blog. I know the negative comments will bring people on both sides of the issue to post their views. It’s ironic that the negative commentators warning of traffic decline are in fact helping to increase traffic.

People Who Say They’re Leaving Don’t

No one really completely leaves a site. They may not visit as often as they used to but it’s rare for anyone to never come back. I’ve had commentators post that my blog had changed for the worst and they’re leaving and never coming back. The next day, they’re flaming me again for another post.

How To Handle A Negative Comment

The best way to handle a negative comment is to thank the reader for making it and then address his concerns. Never flame the reader even if he flames you. That makes you look extremely unprofessional. While you can edit a negative comment for profanity, you should never delete it. A comment is the same as content and content drives traffic.

The next time you read a few negative comments on your blog, don’t look at it as a bad thing. Instead, it’s a sign that your blog is growing and you’re doing something right. If you never get a negative comment on your blog, you’re doing it wrong.

Did you enjoy this post? Get John Chow Dot Com updates via email...

Stay up to date with all of John Chow’s tips for making money online and blog posts by subscribing via email. Your email will be kept private and never shared with anyone.

Comments have been disabled for this post.
Sort: Newest | Oldest

I heard John Chow is going to turn this site into a food review website only! Uh oh! :grin:

Good post!

-Sam from MarketMatador.com

I agree john. You're doing find, keep doing what you do best!

I try not to leave negative comments, only constuctive critism.

good post john. I think that negative comments are great for a site (as long as they are constructive). However, i think its important for any webmaster to take on board any comments that are made.

im a huge fan of your blog and in particular, your writing style. However, in two of my posts i have critized your blog for 2 things.

1. All reviews are 100% positive. I find myself skipping most reviews now as they are always 100% positive. I understand that you might be rejecting sites for review that you dont like however it's hard to not lose faith in your reviews when there is little of no negative aspects in the review. If there is no criticism then the reviews come across as advertisements or sales talk.

2. The review me for a link. There has been nearly 60 posts linking back for people who have helped you google bomb your site higher in the rankings for the term 'make money online'. I understand you want to pay those back who linked you etc however im sure many other readers like myself get bored reading these posts very quickly. You have written some great posts about making money line and promoting blogs however i fail to see how these get rich quick linking schemes are gonna help any blog long term.

i hope you dont think im being too negative as i enjoy reading this blog. However, i think that the blog should concentrate more on helping others making money instead of yourself.

that being said, hope your enjoying your stay in canada :):)

In no way am I being combative here, but I just wanted to say that not all ReviewMe posts are 100% positive. If John found something, well, questionable he certainly said something about it. As far as making money for himself vs helping others, I think the whole premise of this blog is just that -- to help others earn while generating revenue. A huge chunk of his earnings go to charities anyway, right, so I don't see anything wrong with that at all.

This blog basically has it all -- travel, food, new gadgets, great deals and freebies, evil contests, and reviews that are, admit it, useful for a lot of us mogul dot com wannabes. Some might think it's ambitious, but it could mean for the better. :smile:

Yes, that whole post may be true, but I don't call it "growth" when someone attacks you personally calling you names and saying your dirty and a moron just because you like a certain sport.

I don't mind it because infact it'd be great to marge all 3 of my blogs into a monster blog about me, seo etc, and my geek crap but its a hard thing to do. john does it well.

i agree, johns posts about fine dining and cars definitely add to the flavor of the blog, and help remind us why we're trying to make money online - so we can enjoy those things too!

Funny I see this post just after having thought about the subject. I have not been reading this blog for a long time but have noticed that the content is turning more towards advertising and pointless fillers in between. I still enjoy reading the reviews just to get another person's point of view but there is not much left on the blog which seems to be personal.
Nothing wrong with that but I see a trend with other blogs trying to mimic this concept and it's a shame to think that blogs are turning into the next spam medium.
Also one thing I can't get my head round is the way some people seem to worship John. He's just another guy with another blog that happens to get more traffic than others.
Big deal?

"Worship" might be too much, Bob. I think it's more like an esteemed "high five" -- yeah, that's it. :smile:

"If you’re not pissing somebody off, you’re not doing it right" -- this goes on my words-to-live-by list. :twisted:

i hope your site gets hacked again cause it sucks now! :lol: :lol:

You cannot please everyone -- that's the whole point of it. Even if you're the most likable person in the world, some people could still say nasty stuff about you. But do you cry, throw a fit, go against your principles and retaliate? Perhaps...it won't solve anything though; negative comments are just gonna keep on popping up. It's up to you to dish out or dismiss.

Don't worry John we still like you :)

I'm totally leaving you, John! Except when you have food reviews. I get hungry, ya know.

I'll believe it when I see it! :)

I have to agree with you John in one thing, you and nobody will never be able to make everybody happy, and if anybody ever try it, He/She will be the only unhappy 'cause will never make it.!

I predict John will get at least half a dozen free link backs due to the buzz on this post :)

Anyone else notice that this post has the most comments on a post in a while? Go figure. Even talking about negative comments will get you traffic.... :roll:

:???:

Well, I took the comments off of my mommmy blog because some crazed fan (of a boy band my daughter LOVES), made really ugly comments. I WILL NOT allow someone to fry my kids...especially when it's uncalled for. It was a fit of jealousy that I could not condone. Then she lied about her age and even had her friends come over and comment too. That blog is about autism, parenting and my day to day life with 7 kids. I will not allow strangers to attack my kids ... ever.

So, I turned on the comment moderation. I also had to do the same on another blog because a pretty popular blogger attacked me. Whatever. He has his way of doing things and I have mine. But when he gets on his soap box about poverty, which he knows nothing about....that's another story. Being a single mom, is hard enough. Having someone that never went through the hell I've been through, talk down to me and try to minimize my situation....I let him have it. He got upset...

He and a few readers decided to pick on the new blogger, I let him have it and then shut off the comments. I try to keep my blogs family friendly. I didn't want my readers to be offended.

Besides, isn't your blog your KINGDOM?
:mrgreen:

People will always have their own opinion, but there are certain things that are off limits. My kids are one of them!

It obviously depends on the kind of blog you have and the types of negative comments you get. There is a big difference between "you're wrong about ___" and "you're a bitch." The second one has nothing constructive to say. It's just hateful. That's all.

I turned my comments off and I am so glad I did. Moderating and responding to hateful comments ate up too much of my time. People can go call me names somewhere else, thank you.

I for one love how your blog has turned out currently. And a few days ago I read through all of your 100+ page history so I pretty much saw it all from start to finish.

I like the ReviewMe's since they tend to be about newer online services which gives your blog a Lifehacker blog feel so it keeps me up to date on new stuff to market.

Anyone who has a problem with the reviews really needs to think outside of the box, they are a way to make money online, they tell you what's might be the next fad.

I also absolutely love your fine dining posts, but then again cooking is a passion of mine, and those posts are what keeps me coming back every day more then anything else.

So here's one vote for keep up the good work.

I very much enjoyed your comments on negative blogging and read them out here in the office.

Its true that polarizing people is often a characteristic of the most popular blogs.

I suppose the only thing to watch out for is that you are in fact polarizing (i.e. there are people on both sides) and not just alienating. As a regular reader and a subscriber for the last few months, I'm confident that you couldn't alienate everyone even if you tried :-)

John Chow, you Smirnoff drinking SOB!!! You suck and your blog sucks. I hate you. You are the worst person ever!!! On top of that, you are Canadian. How bad can it get?!?!

-I only made this negative comment because per your post, it's good for you.

You can promote agloco 1000 times a day but can you at least eat something that looks like real food and not some kind of dog turd?

The Miscellaneous Ramblings of a Dot Com Mogul that eats shit and makes money to post pictures of it...

Thanks John, you are a genious :) Now i got some ideas for reply some negative comments ;)

HAHA..
You suckers. He got you to link to him with "make money online". I bet your blogs didnt get anything out of it hahaha. Now he make money by posting ads (revieme)everyday hahaha. GO John you evil marketer.

Can you handle all these somewhat negative comments , John? :mrgreen:

fantastic post!

I've left negative comments although never threatened to not return!

But I do enjoy reading the blog and enjoy the fact that it stirs up my juices every now and then!

I agree, this is a great post!, I even have you this blog sindicated in my google Reader page!

Excellent topic to address John, and a fantastic position on it.

Controversy and different opinions are what make the Internet such a great place to be - a good debate never hurt anybody.

True...it only gets ugly when people veer away from the idea of a "healthy debate" and just launch their unrestrained displeasure if only to be downright mean.

Sure, the negative comments helps, but the blog must be protected against spam because so usually filters the spammers to have an open door.

Sure but spam is a completely different issue altogether. Negative comments are just people who have less nice things to say about your blog.

Instead of criticizing John's site, here are a few options to make this better:

1) Raise the ReviewMe price to $500. Less posts = same money or more

2) Less food posts, but more hot chicks post. I'm sure none of these guys would complain. It should be a hot chick post for every food post. I don't care who, just slap a hot model somewhere on a post; no words needed.

3) On the sidebar, create a top ten latest make money online posts. Hence, this would satisfy the whiners.

www.hustlermoneyblog.com
Make Money without a blog

Ummm, just a gentle reminder. Not all of John's readers are male :neutral:

Yes, I love comments, even my negative ones!

Little do many of the negative commentators know, they're helping to refresh my page and add even more good SEO content to the posts they don't agree with.

And then the commentators sometimes get into fights with each other.

I leave the curse words out there, too. Many people just need to vent. Plus, it helps SEO -- you'd be surprised the heinous search terms people type in that include curse words coupled with other terms.

I only deleted a few bad comments I received as a knee jerk reaction after posting my Kramer post, but I wish I'd left those out there too.

I still like your blog. :) I don't care of food post, and review me post. If i don't like that post, i will skip it. :D I read the post that i like.

negative on that one John. I read your blog almost since the beginning and its become complete shit and alot of other agree with me. Your losing alot of your readership. Your 15 minutes are up. Go get rolled.

People keep saying this, but it's not true. Have you been looking at his monthing visitor statistics? His readership is going up, not down.

You come across comments and readers full of animosity, yet you wonder 'what are they still doing here?' :roll:

If John likes negative comments, then this one has got to make his day :mrgreen:

Hi John

I from Argentina and read your blog every day.

I have a question.

What happen with www.laptopgamers.com?

John chow the most evil blogger earth :twisted: